Home
Shopping
Rewards
Clearance
Seasonal
Did You Know?
Locations
About Us
Contact Us
Home
Products
Categories
2024 Keepsake Videos
2024 Keepsakes
Accessories
Barbie™
Christmas Movies
Classic Christmas Style
Comics
Disney
Faith and Inspiration
Gaming
Halloween
Harry Potter™
Hobbies and Interests
Holiday Humour
Light, Sound and Motion
Limited Edition
Love, Baby and Family
Miniature Ornaments and Trees
Movies and TV
Peanuts®
SCI-FI and Fantasy
Series Favourites
Sports
Toys and Characters
Vehicles
2 for $29.99 Hallmark Mugs
70% off 2023 Keepsakes
Angels/Memorial
Angels
Memorial
Baby/Kids
Albums and Memory books
Banks
Baptism/Christening
Board books
Expecting
Faith
Frames
Licensed
New family
Plush
Recordable books/plush
Room Décor
Candles
Collections
Friends TV Series
Gilmore Girls TV Series
Golden Girls TV Series
Indiana Jones
Shitts Creek
Yellowstone
Confirmation/Communion
Communion
Confirmation
Faith/Religious
Gifts for Her
Frames
Gifting
Jewelry box/Jewelry
Mugs/Travel Mugs
Socks
Tableware
Gifts for Him
Cars/Trucks
Frames
Gifting
Motorcycles
Mugs/Travel Mugs
Socks
Tableware
Graduation
Frames
Keepsakes
Misc.
Mugs
Socks
Growing Up Girls
Laser Engraving
Licensed Characters
Disney
Gaming
Harry Potter
Harry Potter DEPT.56
Other Licensed products
Peanuts
Star Trek
Star Wars
Superhero
Mother’s Day
Candles
Frames
Misc.
Mugs
Willow Tree
PEI Gifting
Pet
Cat
Dog
Memorial
Professions
Farming
Firefighter/Police
Nurse/Doctor
Teacher
Puzzles/Games
100/350 Pc
1000 Pc
2000+ Pc
500-550 Pc
Games
Licensed
Metal Earth Models
Remembrance/Sympathy
Remembrance
Sympathy
Retirement
Frames
Memory Keeping
Mugs
Party Supplies
Rewards Hallmark Candles
Wedding/Anniversary/Love
Anniversary
Love
Wedding
Willow Tree
Family/Pet
Friendship
Hope/Healing
Love/Wedding/Anniversary
Nativity/Tree Toppers
New Baby
Spiritual/Milestone
Sympathy/Remembrance
Teacher/Grad
Thank You
Seasonal
Categories
Confirmation/Communion
Graduation
Rewards
Clearance
Did You Know?
Locations
About Us
Contact Us
"MVP of My Heart" Baseball 1ERL1215
$19.99
Combine your loved one's two favorite passions with our "MVP of My Heart" baseball. Made of simulated leather, the ball features heart-shaped red stitching and comes in a gift box. Makes a playful anytime gift for the baseball fanatic in your life.
On packaging: MVP OF MY HEART
Simulated leather.
Includes newly updated gift box.
3" W x 3" H x 3" D
Related Products
Elements Bird Figurine Grandma 3.5" PA82463
$23.99
Mom Loves Forever Sentiment 1WOD4023
$14.99
My Mother's Garden Book 1BOK1572
$19.99
Nana Shows Love Framed Quote Sign, 7x7 1SNN1131
$25.99
New Mom Daily Affirmations Light-Up Frame With 12 Quotes 1BBY4903
$38.99
Lighthouse Night Light 136569
$34.99
DaySpring Shine Goodness Tealight Holder 1REL2053
$29.99
Moms Just Want To Have Fun Slippers With Sound, S/M-L/X-L 1SLP1016-1017
$32.99
Mom - 8 oz - 100% Soy Wax Candle Scent: Tranquility PA19548
$25.99
Elements Mother 8" 82471
$39.99
Every Kind of Mom Framed Quote Sign, 7x7 1SNN1130
$25.99
Peanuts® Snoopy Plush Gift Card Holder, 4.2" 1PAJ3561
$12.99
Daughter - Stacking Mug and Candle Set 100% Soy Wax Scent: Tranquility PA78306
$29.99
DaySpring Be Still and Know Throw Blanket With Tassels, 50x60 1REL2048
$44.99
Morgan Harper Nichols Tea Towel 1MRG1005
$16.99
Spa Day Self-Care Kit 1WEL1065
$38.99
DaySpring Walk in Love Tote 1REL2023
$51.99
She’s More Than My Friend, She’s My Sister Book 1BOK1067
$12.95
Stop and Smell the Rosé 1BOK1574
$16.99
Welcome To Our Home Hanging Sign With Seasonal Decorations, 18x18 - 1SNN1128
$44.99
Stuff Every Wine Snob Should Know 1BOK1511
$12.99
Disney Mickey Mouse Plush Gift Card Holder 1DYG2115
$12.99
Abstract Floral Tote Bag 1ART1020
$44.99
Love - Stacking Mug and Candle Set 100% Soy Wax Scent: Tranquility PA78309
$29.99
Happy Wife Stemless Glass 21727
$21.99
Spoontiques Grandkids Long Wood Sign SPTQ21965
$19.99
Kind - Stacking Mug and Candle Set 100% Soy Wax Scent: Tranquility PA78310
$29.99
Elements Guardian Angel 9" PAV82310
$44.99
Elements Godmother 6" 82303
$29.99
Spoontiques Grandkids Desk Sign SPTQ19746
$19.99
Be the Rainbow Sprinkle Tea Towel 1BRW3223
$16.99
Spoontiques Mom Long Wood Sign SPTQ21973
$19.99
In Our Home We Do Love Wood Sign Family Handprint Kit 1BBY4850
$44.99
Elements Love You Mom 7.5 PA82450
$39.99
Morgan Harper Nichols Decorative Pillow 1MRG1002
$44.99
Ladybug Ceramic Planter 1ART1018
$32.99
Guardian Angel - 4" Photo Frame Ornament PA85313
$16.99
Forever Friends - 4" Photo Frame Ornament PA85315
$16.99
Godmother - 9 oz - 100% Soy Wax Candle Scent: Tranquility PA52121
$23.99
Elements Cat Mom 6 PA82453
$29.99
Grandma - 9 oz - 100% Soy Wax Candle Scent: Tranquility PA52120
$23.99
Elements Grandmother 8" PA82297
$39.99
A Mother's Love - Musical Water Globe 82329
$52.99
Sisters - 8 oz - 100% Soy Wax Candle Scent: Tranquility PA13223
$21.99
My Happy Place Hardcover Notebook HWJ7046
$16.99
Grandma Like You - 9" Angel Holding a Butterfly PA33242
$32.99
DC Comics™ Wonder Woman 1984™ Hero Mom Metal Quote Sign and Stand SHR1943
25%
$14.99
$19.99
Wonder Woman Apron 16429
$34.99
Ship Wheel & Anchor Night Light 136566
$34.99
Heart Pillow With Pocket 1ERL1212
$29.99
Abstract Floral Mug With Crew Socks, Set of 2 1ART1009
$32.99
Sister-In-Law Like You - 10 oz - 100% Soy Wax Reveal Candle Scent: Tranquility PA33208
$29.99
Bless This House Layered Square Quote Sign, 8x8 - 1SNN1148
$32.99
Daughter-In-Law Like You - 10 oz - 100% Soy Wax Reveal Candle Scent: Tranquility PA33207
$29.99
Strawberry-Shaped Trinket Dish 1ART1002
$12.99
Ask Grandma Layered Square Quote Sign, 8x8 - 1SNN1141
$32.99
Big Fan of God's Plan Canvas Tote Bag 1FAI1220
$51.99
Elements Bird Figurine Family 4 PA82462
$24.99
A Friend's Love Angel Figurine, 6" 1JOA2236
$28.99
Go With God Keychain1FAI1227
$16.99
Friend - 8 oz - 100% Soy Wax Candle Scent: Tranquility PA13224
$21.99
Friends - Musical Water Globe PA82304
$52.99
Nana - Stacking Mug and Candle Set 100% Soy Wax Scent: Tranquility PA78304
$29.99
SEGA Sonic the Hedgehog™ Tape Dispenser 1NIT1016
$58.99
Elements Bird Figurine Friend 3.5" 82466
$23.99
Etched in a Mom's Heart Angel Figurine, 8.75" 1JOA2106
$38.99
Greatly Grandma All the Reasons 1BOK1048
$12.95
Elements Family 4.5" PA82444
$17.99
This Family Tan Fringed Tea Towel, 18x26 1SNN1145
$19.99
Gnome Ornament Female Mechanic 3OT4902GMD
$14.99
Because She's Nana 1BOK1503
$12.99
Beautiful Grandma Angel Figurine, 8.6" 1JOA2234
$38.99
Memories for My Grandchild PP332943
$22.99
Cat Mom Stemless Glass 21726
$21.99
Sister - 9 oz - 100% Soy Wax Candle Scent: Tranquility PA52119
$23.99
Best Mommy Hands Down Wood Sign Handprint Kit 1BBY4849
$32.99
BOGO Vanilla Sugar Cake 3-Wick Jar Candle, 16 oz. - 1BGC1083
$38.99
Elements Friendship 5.5 PAV82424
$26.99
Shining Sun Round Trinket Dish 1ART1003
$12.99
Faith, Hope, Love Blue Canvas Pouch 1FAI1221
$25.99
My Soul Stays Restored Trinket Dish My Soul Stays Restored Trinket Dish 1FAI1226
$19.99
Daughter, A Precious Gift Angel Figurine, 3.8" 1JOA2237
$21.99
Sand Dollar Night Light 136571
$34.99
Joy in the Journey Foldable Shopping Tote 1ART1019
$19.99
Elements Daughter Guardian Angel 6 82403
$24.99
Nana - 4
$16.99
WT Angel Of Friendship DD26011
$41.99
Grandma - 4" Photo Frame Ornament PA85305
$16.99
Disney Winnie the Pooh Framed Quote Sign, 10x10 - 1DYG2110
$38.99
To Do List: World Domination Tea Towel 1BRW3224
$16.99
Spoontiques Betty Boop Apron SPTQ16450
$34.99
Elements Bird Figurine Love You 3 PA82468
$21.99
Mommy and Me Ceramic Cup Gift Set P2995006
$34.99
A Sister Is a Blessing Angel Figurine, 8.5" 1JOA2096
$38.99
Mom - 8 oz - 100% Soy Wax Candle Scent: Tranquility PA13222
$21.99
Mom - 3.5" Bird Figurine PA82464
$23.99
Tough as a Mother Sentiment 1SNN1034
$25.99
WT Our Healing Touch DD28041
$104.99
True Friends - 9 oz - 100% Soy Wax Candle Scent: Tranquility PA52137
$23.99
Abstract Floral Reversible Picnic Blanket, 50x50 1ART1023
$44.99
Sister Like You - 9" Double Angels Holding Butterflies PA33244
$39.99
Mom Delivers Blue Fringed Tea Towel, 18x26 1SNN1139
$19.99
Lady Bug Scalloped Trinket Dish 1ART1006
$25.99
Love Is All We Need Ceramic Keepsake Box 1ERL1207
$44.99
I Can Do All Things Lidded Trinket Dish With Metal Token - 1KFA2019
$25.99
DaySpring This Is the Day Spiral Weekly Calendar 1REL2043
$16.99
Elements Niece 4.5 PAV82350
$17.99
Rainbow Angel Ornament ACRY-278
$12.99
Amazing - 9 oz - 100% Soy Wax Candle Scent: Tranquility PA52138
$23.99
One of the Groomed Ones Travel Nail Kit 1FMN3025
$25.99
Spoontiques Elvis Air Freshener SPTQ10015
$10.99
Mom - 4" Photo Frame Ornament PA85303
$16.99
Daughter Like You - 3.5" Ceramic Keepsake Box PA33216
$14.99
Tropical Light Up Pineapple ACRY493
$23.99
Godmother - Stacking Mug and Candle Set 100% Soy Wax Scent: Tranquility PA78318
$29.99
Ears That Listen - Grandma Candle CDL1029
$29.99
Dog - Stacking Mug and Candle Set 100% Soy Wax Scent: Tranquility PA78308
$29.99
Running on Faith White Baseball Cap 1FAI1225
$25.99
Elements Granddaughter 5.5 PAV82349
$26.99
Wonderfully Made Striped Canvas Pouch With Wrist Strap
$21.99
Crystal Love Snail Figure ACRYV-77
$14.99
Best Grandma Hands Down Wood Sign Handprint Kit 1BBY4848
$32.99
Stepping Stone - Mom ER67016
$29.99
Cupcake Recordable Plush, 8.5
$32.99
In Full Bloom Ceramic Planter 1ART1024
$25.99
Hallmark Channel Sip Sip Hooray Water Tumbler, 22 oz. 1HKC2330
$25.99
Mom - 9 oz - 100% Soy Wax Candle Scent: Tranquility PA52118
$23.99
Hogwarts Crest Apron 16489
$34.99
Wonderfully Made Striped Canvas Pouch With Wrist Strap 1FAI1222
$21.99
Positive Vibes and Coffee Slippers With Sound, Small/Medium 1SLP1013
$32.99
Elements Bird Figurine Godmother 3 PA82469
$21.99
Family - Stacking Mug and Candle Set 100% Soy Wax Scent: Tranquility PA78311
$29.99
CARDINAL SUNCATCHER 20968
$17.99
Friend Like You - 9" Angel Holding a Bird PA33241
$32.99
You're my Hero, Dad Book BOK2212
$12.95
Beer Bottle Cap Coaster (4 pc. set) CB175334
$21.99
Best Papa Ever Trophy-Shaped Quote Sign, 5.3x6 1SNN1143
$21.99
Spoontiques Dad Desk Sign SPTQ19786
$19.99
Baseball Handprint Kit 1BBY4791
$21.99
Thirst Aid Pint Glass 1BRW3228
$19.99
Block Talk Dad ASSORTED ER67365
$6.99
GUITAR CLOCK Item #: 29081
$54.99
Pint Glass and Coaster Book Bundle SKU: 1FMN3039
$32.99
Man, Myth, Mischief-Maker Trinket Tray 1SNN1133
$25.99
Galvanized Beer Bottle Cap Wall Decor (Sold Separately) 146280
$37.99
WT My Guy WT Figurine DD28042
$65.99
Dad Gone Viral Book BOK2253
$12.95
Best Grandpa Ever Trophy-Shaped Quote Sign, 5.3x6 1SNN1144
$21.99
#1 Dad Pennant-Shaped Trinket Tray 1SNN1132
$21.99
Leader of the Pack Pint Glass 1BRW3229
$19.99
Hero Dad Layered Square Quote Sign, 8x8 - 1SNN1142
$32.99
Remote Caddy Assorted ER78843
$32.99
ACDC - 3 PACK CREW SOCK SET BCCRM064JADC
$24.99
Garage Clock FK23716
$54.99
Whiskey Set TPW638
$43.99
Dad's Grill Cutting Board ER78701
$31.99
Beer is a Friend Pint Glass 1BRW3227
$19.99
Dad Multitool Keychain EAE232
$7.99
Wood Treasure/Memory Box 11x7.5x7 ET2927
$59.99
Better Together Embroidered Blanket 1SNN1032
$64.99
25th Anniversary Ornament - Silver ER73801
$19.99
25 with Double Rings 6x4 Anniversary Frame SE1316
$32.99
My Promise Book 1BOK1480
$19.99
General Anniversary Ornament - Copper ER73803
$19.99
Tells a Story Photo Frame FK39767
$39.99
50 with Double Rings 6x4 Anniversary Frame SE1317
$32.99
25th Anniversary Ribbon Frame 9.25x.5x9.5 KC4362
$36.99
Forever Treasure/Card Box ET8834
$56.99
40th Anniversary Frame with Rhinestones R19449
$49.99
Love Bird Anniversary Ornament - 25th ER64226
$14.99
WT Together DD26032
$63.99
50 Years Together Ceramic Picture Frame FRG6015
$29.99
Porcelain Frame - 25 Years in Love ER67161
$34.99
Frame 5X7 Frosted Silver Frame w/Crystal Double Heart KC735
$32.99
Frame White 50th Anniversary 4 x 6 SW7032
$17.99
Spoontiques All Because Two People Fell in Love SPTQ19773
$19.99
Pure White Epoxy Wedding Frame with Heart Swirls 8 X 10 KC678W
$41.99
Love Means Everything Quote Sign, 7.5x9 1BMK1615
$21.99
Love You and Love You More Mugs, Set of 2 1ERL1194
$34.99
Love Bird Anniversary Ornament - 50th ER64227
$14.99
Love Story Photo Frame FK39764
$39.99
Ornament - The Key To A Happy Marriage ER15311
$14.99
50th White Anniversary Frame 6x4 SW7032
$17.99
25 Years of Us Silver Anniversary Picture Frame, 5x7 1ERL1203
$38.99
Then and Now Ceramic Picture Frame, Holds 2 Photos 1ERL1205
$44.99
WD. BOX-EVERY LOVE STORY/BEAUTIFUL ET1411
$49.99
Still in Love - 5" x 8" Photo Frame PA74613
$19.99
Married For Life Book 1BOK1477
$19.99
WT You and Me DD26439
$63.99
White 40th Anniversary Frame 6x4 SW7031
$17.99
Anniversary Silver Ribbon 3.5 x 5 and 4x6 Oval Opening KC4352
$36.99
Lucky Me and Lucky You Mugs, Set of 2 1ERL1209
$38.99
25th Anniversary Frame with Rhinestones R19218
$49.99
WT Anniversary DD26184
$63.99
50TH Anniversary Frame 6x4 MT513A5
$29.99
Wedding Day and 50th Anniversary Frame 4x6 KC368W
$49.99
Love Bird Anniversary Ornament - Happy Anniversary ER64228
$14.99
25th White Anniversary Frame 6x4 SW7030
$17.99
Wedding Cake Figurine - 25th Anniversary ER56662
$14.99
XO Stemless Champagne Flutes, Set of 2 1ERL1188
$38.99
50th Anniversary Ornament - Gold ER73802
$19.99
40th Anniversary Ribbon Frame 9.25x.5x9.5 KC4382
$36.99
25th Anniversary Then/Now Frame 4x6 KC365W
$49.99
Porcelain Frame - 50 Years in Love ER67162
$34.99
Wood/Black 50th Anniversary Frame SW2350
$17.99
Mr. and Mrs. Wine Mug Set EAE212S
$49.99
Elements Anniversary 6" PA82476
$29.99
Jewellery Box with Rings AT744
$23.99
Wood/Black 25th Anniversary Frame SW2325
$17.99
50th Anniversary Frame with Rhinestones R19234
$49.99
Spoontiques Mrs. Always Right Camper Mug SPTQ21518
$19.99
Two Hearts Bridal Photo Frame Plaque ER79001
$34.99
Wifey/Hubby Couple Aprons ONE153
$31.99
Love Wedding Guest Book With Pen 1EDY2047
$34.99
25th Anniversary Frame 6x4 MT513A2
$29.99
Spoontiques Mr. Right Camper Mug SPTQ21517
$19.99
50th Anniversary Ribbon Frame 9.25x.5x9.5 KC4392
$36.99
50 Years of Us Golden Anniversary Picture Frame, 5x7 1ERL1204
$38.99
CHOIL Husband & Wife Mug 4004610
$19.99
HM Mr. Mug, 16 oz. 1MUG3577
$21.99
HM Mrs. Mug, 16 oz. 1MUG3578
$21.99
Disney Winnie the Pooh Quote Mug, 17.5 oz. - 1DYG2116
$21.99
Silver/Heart picture frame 8x10 KC1148
$44.99
Here's to Love Picture Frame, 4x6 1ERL1186
$29.99
Ceramic Cup O' Java, 17 OZ., Wedding Giftset of 2 Sku: 3MCF005
$44.99
TYING THE KNOT ULTIMATE WEDDING PLANNER PP330833
$39.99
Elements To Love 6 PAV82434
$25.99
Wood Photo Frame with Metal "Love" 6x4 SW7246L
$17.99
MY WEDDING ORGANIZER PP317285
$39.99
His And Hers Change Box CB026
$27.99
©Disney Mickey and Minnie Wedding Frame 6001368
$59.99
WT Promise DD26121
$63.99
Loved Bracelets set of 4 SKU: 1REL1081
$32.99
HM Floral Heart Mug, 16 oz.1MUG3545
$21.99
HM Cheers! Engagement Mug, 16 oz. 1MUG3569
$21.99
Loved - 4.5" Faux Leather Plaque PA27165
$11.99
Newlyweds' Survival Guide Book and Gift Card Holder 1BOK1469
$16.99
Heart Swirls 5x7 Wedding Frame KC675W
$26.99
WEDDING PLANNER CHECKLIST PP321541
$9.99
WT Around You DD27182
$82.99
Musical Wedding Cake Globe WM1604
$45.99
Flower Girl - 4.25" Angel w/Basket Flowers pa74610
$19.99
Love is Patient Frame R19899
$49.99
Spoontiques Mrs. Always Right Travel Mug 12765
$24.99
Wedding Cake Figurine - Wedding Day ER56661
$14.99
Wedding Reception Guest Book Autograph Puzzle 1ERL1214
$32.99
Mr. and Mrs. Champagne Flutes TGY512
$27.99
WT 2024 Ornament DD28253
$31.99
White Happily Ever After Frame AHF4778
$21.99
Rustic Chic - Countdown Calendar ER49764
$27.99
Make-Up Bell EJ2740
$34.99
Here's to Forever Ceramic Picture Frame, 5x7 1FRG6013
$29.99
Always & Forever Wedding Photo Album EDY3161
$44.99
Mr. Rectangular Trinket Tray 1ERL1210
$21.99
Junior Bridesmaid - 6" Angel Holding Bouquet PA74611
$19.99
CHOIL Wedding Mug 4050621
$19.99
A Happy Beginning Wedding Planner 3-Ring Binder EDY2050
$64.99
An Angel for the Bride Charms ER50660
$4.99
Mr Mrs Large Platter Item: 6005721
$44.99
Mr and Mrs Keychain Set Roman10638
$27.99
WT Around You Cake Topper DD27342
$63.99
Wedding Angel Wings Orn 6009575
$29.99
Mrs. Round Trinket Tray 1ERL1211
$21.99
Spoontiques Mr. Right Travel Mug 12764
$24.99
Yes to Love Wedding Slippers With Sound, Small/Medium 1SLP1008
$32.99
CHOIL Groom Mug 4053087
$19.99
×