Home
Shopping
Rewards
Clearance
Seasonal
Did You Know?
Locations
About Us
Contact Us
Home
Products
Categories
Everyday 2025 Keepsakes
75% off 2024 Keepsakes
Classic Christmas Style
Comics
Disney
Faith and Inspiration
Gaming
Harry Potter™
Hobbies and Interests
Holiday Humour
Light, Sound and Motion
Limited Edition
Love, Baby and Family
Miniature Ornaments and Trees
Movies and TV
Peanuts®
SCI-FI and Fantasy
Series Favourites
Toys and Characters
Vehicles
Angels/Memorial
Angels
Memorial
Baby/Kids
Albums and Memory books
Banks
Baptism/Christening
Board books
Expecting
Faith
Frames
Licensed
New family
Plush
Recordable books/plush
Room Décor
Birthday
Candles
Collections
Bridgerton
Friends TV Series
Gilmore Girls TV Series
Golden Girls TV Series
Indiana Jones
Shitts Creek
Yellowstone
Confirmation/Communion
Communion
Confirmation
Dumpster Fire 🔥
Easter
Gifting
Plush
Faith/Religious
Gifts for Her
Frames
Gifting
Jewelry box/Jewelry
Mugs/Travel Mugs
Socks
Tableware
Gifts for Him
Cars/Trucks
Frames
Gifting
Motorcycles
Mugs/Travel Mugs
Socks
Tableware
Graduation
Frames
Keepsakes
Misc.
Mugs
Growing Up Girls
HM Rewards 2 for $27
HM Candles Mix and Match
HM Mugs Mix and match.
HM Socks Mix and Match
HM Tea Towles Mix and Match
Laser Engraving
Licensed Characters
Disney
Gaming
Harry Potter
Harry Potter DEPT.56
Other Licensed products
Peanuts
Star Trek
Star Wars
Superhero
Memories Books
Interactive Journals
Kids Journals
PEI Gifting
Pet
Cat
Dog
Memorial
Professions
Farming
Firefighter/Police
Nurse/Doctor
Teacher
Puzzles/Games
100/350 Pc
1000 Pc
2000+ Pc
500-550 Pc
Games
Licensed
Metal Earth Models
Remembrance/Sympathy
Remembrance
Sympathy
Retirement
Frames
Memory Keeping
Mugs
Party Supplies
Wedding/Anniversary/Love
Anniversary
Love
Wedding
Willow Tree
Family/Pet
Friendship
Hope/Healing
Love/Wedding/Anniversary
Nativity/Tree Toppers
New Baby
Spiritual/Milestone
Sympathy/Remembrance
Teacher/Grad
Thank You
Seasonal
Categories
Confirmation/Communion
Graduation
Rewards
Clearance
Did You Know?
Locations
About Us
Contact Us
PRAYING BEAR HE10457
$27.99
Related Products
3 PC SLV Cutlery Set CN7500
$26.99
Christening Lamb HE10532
$39.99
WT Little One DD27922
$65.99
Holy Baptism - 7.5" Angel Holding Baby PA82479
$43.99
Elements Godmother 6" 82303
$29.99
Sweet Prayer Bear BG4539
$29.99
Baby Girl Rosary and Cross Set R40409
$31.99
Valencia Girl Guardian Cross R60898
$22.99
Jesus Love Me Lamb HE10458
$37.99
Pewter Noah's Ark Money Bank Size4.5 x 2.5 x 3.75 CN2537
$36.99
Baptism Certificate Holder 89420
$29.99
8"H BAPTISM/CHRISTENING CROSS "MAY GOD'S LOVE SURROUND YOU" R44324
$34.99
Baptism with Bible Verse 4x6 Dual Frame CB188567
$39.99
Christening/Faith Frame BBY240
$17.99
GODMOTHER LAPEL PIN ON 4x6in BLESSING CARD ABB-T733
$12.99
KEY RING WITH CROSS CHARM - GODMOTHER 2in ABB-KR585
$16.99
For This Child I Prayed Frame R14166
$32.99
Baptism Stained Glass Keepsake Box R19792
$29.99
GODMOTHER LAPEL PIN ON 4x6in BLESSING CARD ABB-T732
$12.99
Blue ROCKING HORSE TOOTH & CURL BOX SE1032B
$24.99
Lamb with crib cross HE10234
$39.99
Serenity Lamb with Crib Cross HE10233
$39.99
Baptism Handprint, Footprint and Frame 1FRG2173
50%
$19.49
$38.99
Baby Boy Rosary and Cross Set 40408
$31.99
Valencia Boy Guardian Angel Wall Cross R60897
$22.99
Sweet Sentiments Bears BG4240
$25.99
KEY RING WITH CROSS CHARM - GODFATHER 2in ABB-KR586
$17.00
Elements Guardian Angel 9" PAV82310
$44.99
Christening Certificate Tube 38847
$32.99
Christening Frame ER78278
$27.99
Signature Noah's Ark Wood Hallmark Ornament 1HGO3400
$38.99
Serenity Lamb with Crib Cross HE10485
$39.99
Carrots Bunny HE10478
$42.99
itty bittys® Kool-Aid™ Man Cherry-Scented Plush With Sound 1KDD2233
$19.99
itty bittys® Sonic the Hedgehog™ Tails Plush 1KDD2230
$12.99
I Love You Bear Singing Stuffed Animal With Motion, 11" BBY4790
$38.99
Big and Little Bunnies Plush, Set of 2 1BBY4908
$38.99
Twitchie Bunny HE10489
$42.99
Follow My Family Giraffes Plush with Sound and Motion 1BBY4802
$51.99
Story Time Snuggle Bear Plush With Light, 12" - 1KID2202
$51.99
Better Together Star Wars™ Han Solo™ and Chewbacca™ Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.5" 1BTG1008
$29.99
Baby Pig Stuffed Animal, 6" 1KAM2039
$24.99
Better Together Harry Potter™ and Hedwig™ Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.5
$29.99
7 Days of Creation Plush Floor Play Set 1KFA3002
$44.99
Koala with Heart Recordable Plush SKU: 1PSB2191
$32.99
Better Together Lion and Lamb Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.25" KID3015
$21.99
Safari Friends Touch-and-Feel Fabric Book for Kids 1KAM3009
$25.99
Kitten Stuffed Animal, 7.2" 1KAM2042
$24.99
Lamb Plush With Sound, 8" 1KFA4006
$25.99
Strawberry Cow Zip-Along Plush Toy 1KVL2012
$12.99
My First Baby Doll BG3900
$14.99
Big Brother Dinosaur Plush, 11.5" 1BBY4909
$38.99
Gender Reveal Teddy Bear Plush With Ribbons 1BBY4900
$38.99
Learn To Dress Doll BG4387
$36.99
Animal Babies Deer 1KAM2027
$24.99
Light Brown Baby Sloth Stuffed Animal, 6" 1KAM2019
$16.99
Better Together Milk and Cookie Magnetic Plush, 6" 1KID1642
$21.99
Serenity Bear with Sound/Light BG4501
$59.99
Zip-Along Dump Truck Plush Toy KID1704
$12.99
Better Together Burger and Fries Magnetic Plush, 5" 1KID1643
$21.99
Shark Hooded Baby Blanket 1KAM3010
$51.99
Large Better Together Donut and Coffee Magnetic Plush Pair, 12" 1KID1809
$51.99
itty bittys® Star Wars: Ahsoka™ Sabine Wren™ Plush With Helmet 1KDD2200
$12.99
Zip-Along Airplane Plush Toy KID1706
$12.99
Harper Mademoiselle Doll H15116
50%
$19.99
$39.99
Baby Elephant Hooded Blanket With Pockets - 1KAM2033
$51.99
Large Better Together Disney Winnie the Pooh and Piglet Magnetic Plush Pair, 11" 1BTG1015
$51.99
Sun and Cloud Two-Sided Plush, 13" 1KID3020
$38.99
Ocean Friends Touch-and-Feel Fabric Book for Kids 1KAM3007
$25.99
Avery Mademoiselle Doll H15117
50%
$19.99
$39.99
Baby Bunny Hooded Blanket With Pockets - 1KAM2035
$51.99
Baby Lamb Stuffed Animal, 8.5" 1KAM2025
$24.99
itty bittys® Star Wars™ Darth Vader™ Plush With Sound 1KDD2185
$19.99
Better Together Peanuts® Snoopy and Woodstock Magnetic Plush, 5.25" 1BTG1024
$29.99
Animal Baby Elephant Jumbo SKU: 1KAM2021 18
$64.99
Mini Pink Piglet Plush, 5" H 1KAM3001
$16.99
itty bittys® Minecraft Diamond Armor Steve Plush 1KDD2189
$12.99
itty bittys® Harry Potter™ Hermione Granger™ and Victor Krum™ 2 Pack SKU: 1KDD1973
$21.99
Lion Plush With Sound, 8" KFA4007
$25.99
Kissing Cow Plush With Sound, 8" 1KVL2013
$25.99
itty bittys® Jurassic Park Ian Malcom 1KDD2068
$11.99
Birthday Alligator Plush 1KID1552
$25.99
Animal Babies Beaver 1KAM2028
$24.99
Star Wars: The Mandalorian™ Grogu™ Plush Gift Card Holder 1SHP2183
$12.99
itty bittys® biggies Star Wars™ Darth Vader™ Plush, 10" 1SHP2191
$25.99
Baby Giraffe Stuffed Animal, 8" 1KAM2044
$24.99
Rainbow Bunny 11.5" AW82068
$29.99
Better Together Pizza and Ranch Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.5" 1KID1802
$21.99
Animal Baby Elephant Mini, 7.75 KAM2020
$16.99
itty bittys® Disney Stitch Plush With Sound - 1KDD2206
$19.99
itty bittys® Star Trek™ Mirror Mirror Uhura SKU: 1KDD2077
$9.99
itty bittys® Star Wars: The Book of Boba Fett™ Fennec Shand™ Plush 1KDD2165
$16.99
Zip-Along Tugboat Plush Toy KID1705
$12.99
Baby Monkey Stuffed Animal, 8"1KAM2043
$24.99
Baby Bunny Stuffed Animal KAM2009
$16.99
itty bittys® Garfield Plush 1KDD2236
$12.99
itty bittys® Sonic the Hedgehog™ Shadow Plush 1KDD2240
$12.99
Better Together Jumbo Shrimp and Corn Magnetic Plush Pair, 17" 1KID1808
$51.99
Better Together Sushi and Soy Sauce Magnetic Plush, 5.25 1KID1645
$21.99
Madison Mademoiselle Doll H15119
50%
$19.99
$39.99
Better Together Avocado and Toast Magnetic Plush, 5 KID3007
$21.99
Baby Cow Stuffed Animal, 6" 1KAM2022
$16.99
Better Together Broccoli and Cheese Magnetic Plush, 5.75 1KID1649
$21.99
Precious Moments Luffie Lamb with Sound AW15726
$35.99
itty bittys® Star Wars™ Chewbacca™ Plush With Sound - 1KDD2208
$19.99
Better Together Chicken and Waffle Magnetic Plush, 6.75 1KID1646
$21.99
Amazing Grace Lullaby Bear Angel Plush With Sound - 1KFA2020
$38.99
Big and Little Elephant Singing Stuffed Animals With Motion, 8" 1BBY4694
$39.99
Peanuts® 75th Anniversary Floppy Snoopy Plush, 11" 1PAJ4701
$21.99
Better Together Salt and Pepper Magnetic Plush Pair, 5
$21.99
itty bittys® Disney The Little Mermaid Ariel Plush 1KDD2163
$12.99
Better Together Cherry Pie and Ice Cream Magnetic Plush Pair, 5" 1KID1807
$21.99
©Disney Minnie Mouse Stuffed Animal 1BBY4198
$24.99
Better Together Sesame Street Bert and Ernie Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.25" H 1BTG1028
$29.99
Light Brown Baby Sloth Stuffed Animal, 8" 1KAM2026
$24.99
Baby Deer Stuffed Animal, 6.5" 1KAM2023
$16.99
Rainbow Bunny 8" AW82067
$21.99
Baby Elephant Stuffed Animal, 7.75" Mini 1KAM2020
$16.99
Zip-Along Horse Plush Toy KID1703
$12.99
Better Together Star Wars™ Darth Vader™ and Stormtrooper™ Magnetic Plush, 5" 1BTG1005
$29.99
Baby Elephant Stuffed Animal, 8" 1KID1652
$24.99
Squishy Bunnies - 7.5" Gummie - Purple AW82020
$19.99
Squishy Bunnies - 7.5" Gummie - Mint AW82021
$19.99
Disney It's a Small World Map Throw Blanket, 60x52 1DYG2120
$58.99
Better Together Takeout Box and Fortune Cookie Magnetic Plush Pair, 5" 1KID1801
$21.99
Better Together Nickelodeon SpongeBob and Patrick Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.75" 1BTG1011
$29.99
Better Together Cinnamon Roll and Orange Juice Magnetic Plush Pair, 5" 1KID1805
$21.99
Peanuts® Knit Woodstock Plush 1BBY4759
$25.99
Disney Dumbo Plush 1BBY4195
$24.99
Disney Winnie the Pooh Shaped Pillow With Sound - 1DYG2112
$51.99
Baby Boy - 16" Comfort Bear PA19746
$34.99
Chocolate-Scented Brown Bunny Plush, 7" KET5003
$16.99
itty bittys® Minecraft Zombie Plush 1KDD2188
$12.99
Star Wars™ Chewbacca™ Plush With Sound, 11
$44.99
Big Sister Unicorn Plush, 12" 1BBY4910
$38.99
Tulip Bunny HE10475
$39.99
Baby Bunny Stuffed Animal, 8.5" 1KAM2038
$24.99
Puppy Dog Lovey Blanket KAM2030
$24.99
Animal Baby Sloth Mini Stuffed, 6’” KAM2019
$16.99
Better Together Donut and Coffee Magnetic Plush 1KID2092
$21.99
Shark Lovey Blanket 1KAM3006
$24.99
Learn To Dress Doll BG4386
$36.99
itty bittys® Pokémon Pikachu Plush With Light 1KDD2210
$19.99
Gray Shark Plush, 13 KAM3003
$24.99
itty bittys® Marvel Studios X-Men Wolverine Plush 1KDD2228
$12.99
Luffie Prayer Lamb "Now I Lay Me Down To Sleep" Precious Moments Plush with Sound AW15779
$32.99
Better Together Watering Can and Plant Magnetic Plush Pair, 4.5" KID3017
$21.99
Peanuts® 75th Anniversary Through the Years Plush Throw Blanket, 60x52 1PAJ4704
$47.99
itty bittys® Peanuts® 75th Anniversary Snoopy Plush 1KDD2242
$16.99
My Zoo Activity Bag With Finger Puppets 1BBY4820
50%
$16.49
$32.99
itty bittys® biggies Minecraft Creeper Plush, 10” 1NIT1030
$25.99
Better Together Hot Dog and Bomb Pop Magnetic Plush Pair, 3.5" 1KID1803
$21.99
Kangaroo Lovey Blanket 1BBY4824
$19.99
Better Together Ham and Pineapple Magnetic Plush Pair, 7" 1KID1800
$21.99
Better Together Back to the Future Doc and Marty McFly Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.5" H 1BTG1026
$29.99
Grandma and Baby Elephant Stuffed Animal Set, 10 BBY4260
$24.99
Toss-Around Sun Game with Sound and Light SKU: 1PSB2198
$21.99
Squishy Bunnies - 7.5" Gummie - Pink AW82019
$19.99
Orange Crab Plush, 12.75" W 1KAM3005
$24.99
Baby Elephant Lovey Blanket KAM2032
$24.99
Better Together Teacup and Macaron Cookie Magnetic Plush Pair, 3.5" 1KID1806
$21.99
Baby Ganz Big Sister 11 BG3042
$21.99
itty bittys® Harry Potter™ Ron Weasley™ in Dress Robes SKU: 1KDD1870
$9.99
Zip-Along Sheep Plush Toy 1KID3023
$12.99
Lullaby Lamb Plush with Sound / Agneau musical en peluche SKU: 1BBY4720
$38.99
Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Better Together Jack & Sally Magnetic Plush, 5" BTG1002
$29.99
Disney Winnie the Pooh Throw Blanket, 50x60 1DYG2104
$44.99
White Baby Bunny Rabbit Stuffed Animal KET2018
$21.99
Mini Baby Giraffe Stuffed Animal, 6.5" 1KAM2045
$16.99
itty bittys® Star Wars: The Book of Boba Fett™ Boba Fett™ Plush 1KDD2192
$12.99
Better Together Steak and Potato Magnetic Plush, 4.25" 1KID1604
$21.99
Light Brown JUMBO Baby Sloth Stuffed Animal, 20 1KAM2016
$49.99
Springtime Buds (Sold Separately) HE10477
$21.99
Disney Winnie the Pooh Soft Felt Stuffed Animal, 11" DYG2100
$38.99
©Disney Mickey Mouse Lovey 1BBY4193
50%
$9.99
$19.99
Hug 'n' Sing Tootin' Hippo Singing Stuffed Animal With Motion, 10" PSB2193
$38.99
My Friend Jesus Mini Plush Doll, 8" 1KFA4001
$16.99
My Friend Jesus Stuffed Doll, 13" 1KID1655
$21.99
Zip-Along Cow Plush Toy KID1701
$12.99
Floppy Bunny White Oh Hoppy Day Sound AW15753
$21.99
Sloth Plush Stacker 1BBY4689
50%
$14.99
$29.99
Itty Bittys Disney Bambi Baby Lovey Blanket KDD1737
$17.99
Baby Girl - 16" Comfort Bear PA19745
$34.99
Noah Builds an Ark Plush Cloth Baby Book KFA4002
$21.99
Zip-a-Long Bunny Stuffed Animal 1KET1031
$12.99
Peanuts® Beagle Scouts Floppy Snoopy Plush, 10" 1PAJ3551
$21.99
Farm Friends Touch-and-Feel Fabric Book for Kids 1KAM3008
$25.99
Better Together LARGE Star Wars: The Mandalorian™ and Grogu™ Magnetic Plush Pair, 10.5" 1BTG1013
Better Together Minecraft Baby Zombie and Chicken Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.25" H 1BTG1027
$29.99
Nighttime Prayer Pillow and Blanket Set - 1KFA2021
$64.99
Disney Winnie the Pooh Wobble and Chime Plush 1BBY4805
$44.99
Better Together Doughnut and Latte Magnetic Plush, 7" 1KID1639
$21.99
itty bittys® Disney Minnie Mouse Plush 1KDD2243
$12.99
Baby Ganz Night-Night Bear Blue 13 BG4140
$29.99
You're Blessed Bear HE10522
$27.99
Ganz Super Big Brother BG3907
$29.99
Zip-Along Pig Plush Toy 1KID3024
$12.99
Ganz Super Big Sister BG3906
$29.99
Baby Cow Stuffed Animal, 8.25" 1KAM2029
$24.99
Puppy Dog Hooded Blanket With Pockets - 1KAM2031
$51.99
Once Upon a Time Blanket, 50x60 - 1KID2201
$44.99
Better Together Disney Lilo & Stitch Magnetic Plush Pair With Sound, 5.75" H BTG1030
$38.99
Welcome Baby Recordable Bear Plush 1BBY4793
$32.99
Better Together Grapes and Cheese Magnetic Plush, 5.75" KID1656
$21.99
Better Together Caramel and Apple Magnetic Plush, 6.5 1KID1647
$21.99
Woodland Fawn Stuffed Animal 1KID1499
$19.99
Turquoise Sea Turtle Plush, 8" L 1KAM3004
$24.99
Better Together Mac and Cheese Magnetic Plush, 4.73" - 1KID1605
$21.99
itty bittys® Sesame Street® Cookie Monster Plush With Sound 1KDD2115
$19.99
Baby Cow Hooded Blanket With Pockets - 1KAM2037
$51.99
Peanuts® Snoopy Plush Gift Card Holder, 4.2" 1PAJ3561
$12.99
Better Together Ketchup, Mustard and Relish Magnetic Plush Trio, 7.5 1KID1813
$32.99
Disney Mickey Mouse Plush Gift Card Holder 1DYG2115
$12.99
Peek-a-Boo Panda Plush with Sound and Motion 1BBY4800
$44.99
Better Together SEGA Sonic the Hedgehog™ and Tails Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.2" 1BTG1010
$29.99
Kangaroo and Baby Joey Stuffed Animal and Rattle Set 1BBY4819
50%
$19.49
$38.99
Puppy Dog Stuffed Animal, 8" 1KAM2024
$24.99
Blue Octopus Plush, 7" H 1KAM3002
$24.99
Inspirational Praying Lamb HE9700
$26.99
The Lion and The Lamb: A Touch & Feel Book About God's Love 1BBY4854
$21.99
Better Together Star Wars™ R2-D2™ and C-3PO™ Magnetic Plush Pair With Sound BTG1029
$38.99
Better Together BLT and Pickle Magnetic Plush Pair, 4" 1KID1804
$21.99
itty bittys® Disney Goofy Movie Max as Powerline Plush 1KDD2237
$12.99
Twinkle Twinkle Musical Star Plush BBY4823
$38.99
Better Together Pencil and Eraser Magnetic Plush Pair, 6" KID3018
$21.99
itty bittys® Star Wars™ Yoda™ Plush With Sound - 1KDD2207
$19.99
×